Dear Friends and Virginians:
In the 1960’s, there was a beautiful song written entitled “Both Sides Now” by folk singer Joni Mitchell, who lamented her inability to understand modern life.
I can relate.
A few months ago, we were assailed by messages from august personages like President Obama that Democratic-controlled states had to radically restructure their Congressional maps in order to “save democracy.”
The trigger for this existential crisis was, of course, President Trump and his foolish plan to “add” Republican seats in GOP-controlled states like Texas and Florida by redrawing their maps.
Now, the verdict is in: the “map-shifting” was totally irrelevant to Congressional control, except to the extent that Repubs bit themselves on the @ss by losing their own seats in NC, TX and TN.
Our Virginia special election in April and all the ads that went with it? A total waste of time and money.
The Democrats won back control in November, because that’s what happens when you have a large margin in popular vote.
That’s not the only myth demolished by the 2026 election results.
Remember the allegations of “racism” that followed the Supreme Court’s correct ruling that “race-based districts” violate the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution?
Again, the hype failed.
African-American candidates won as both Democrats and Republicans all over Dixie – even in Mississippi, which elected its first black U.S. Senator since Reconstruction.
No matter how you voted last Tuesday — the bottom line is that American democracy is more dynamic than ever.
But don’t wait for anyone to admit that.
So let’s end with Joni’s perfect songwriting:
“Now old friends are acting strange. They shake their heads. They say I’ve changed.”
Well something’s lost but something’s gained from living every day …”
“I’ve looked at life from Both Sides Now. From here and there and up and down.”
“It’s life’s illusions I recall. I really don’t know life at all.”
JCP Notes: A great morning as Sharon pushed me into running the 5-mile Backyard Burn in Clifton. Here’s our photo at the finish line.

Over Thanksgiving, we are traveling to Korea where I’ll be teaching at Sogang University at Seoul and visiting George Mason University at Incheon.
Have a great week!
Peace,
Chap

![“I’ve Looked at [Redistricting] from Both Sides Now”](https://thevirginiaattorney.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Redistricting-Courts-and-Democracy.png)